The First Laser ~ Who Invented

Bright Idea

Who Invented the Laser?

Part of a September 1957 page from Townes’s notebook..

Part of a September 1957 page from Townes’s notebook..

Physicists had been working for generations toward controlling ever shorter wavelengths. After radio (meters) and radar (centimeters, then millimeters), the logical next step would be far-infrared waves. Masers had been modestly useful, more for scientific research than for military or industrial applications. Only a few scientists thought an infrared maser might be important and pondered how to make one. Infrared rays could not be manipulated like radar, and indeed were hard to manage at all.

Arthur Schawlow at Bell Labs, ca. 1960. After a talk with Townes, he realized that an old optical...

Arthur Schawlow at Bell Labs, ca. 1960. After a talk with Townes, he realized that an old optical…

Townes thought about the problems intensively. One day in 1957, studying the equations for amplifying radiation, he realized that it would be easier to make it happen with very short waves than with far-infrared waves. He could leap across the far-infrared region to the long-familiar techniques for manipulating ordinary light. Townes talked it over with his colleague, friend and brother-in-law Arthur Schawlow.

Listen: Arthur Schawlow recalls how Rabi inspired him to make discoveries

Schawlow found the key — put the atoms you wanted to stimulate in a long, narrow cavity with mirrors at each end. The rays would shuttle back and forth inside so that there would be more chances for stimulating atoms to radiate. One of the mirrors would be only partly silvered so that some of the rays could leak out. This arrangement (the Fabry-Pérot etalon) was familiar to generations of optics researchers.

The same arrangement meanwhile occurred to Gordon Gould, a graduate student at Columbia University who had discussed the problem with Townes. For his thesis research, Gould had already been working with “pumping” atoms to higher energy states so they would emit light. As Gould elaborated his ideas and speculated about all the things you could do with a concentrated beam of light, he realized that he was onto something far beyond the much-discussed “infrared maser”. In his notebook he confidently named the yet-to-be-invented device a LASER (for Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation).

Listen: Gordon Gould recalls his creative moment

Listen: Peter Franken recalls hearing Gould’s exciting ideas

Gould, Schawlow and Townes now understood how to build a laser — in principle. To actually build one would require more ideas and a lot of work. Some of the ideas were already in hand. Other physicists in several countries, aiming to build better masers, had worked out various ingenious schemes to pump energy into atoms and molecules in gases and solid crystals. In a way they too were inventors of the laser. So were many others clear back to Einstein.

Gould ca. 1985

Gould ca. 1985

The Patent War Gould ca. 1985

In 1957 Townes talked over some ideas about pumping light-energy into atoms with Gordon Gould, a graduate student who had been thinking along similar lines. Worried that he might be scooped, Gould wrote down his ideas for the record. He developed many more ideas of how lasers could be built and used, and in April 1959 he filed patent applications with his employer, the high-tech research firm TRG. Nine months earlier Schawlow and Townes had applied for a patent on behalf of Bell Laboratories, which employed Schawlow on staff and Townes as a consultant.

When the Bell patent was granted, Gould sued, claiming he was first to conceive the device. Legal battles raged for the next thirty years. If Gould’s patents were valid, everyone who built or used a laser would owe him money—and the longer the patents were undecided, the more valuable they became as the laser industry grew. In 1987 Gould and his backers began to win settlements. One of the greatest patent wars in history was over.

The first page of notes that Gould had notarized in November 1957. He sketched a tube with half…

The first page of notes that Gould had notarized in November 1957. He sketched a tube with half...

The first page of notes that Gould had notarized in November 1957. He sketched a tube with half…

The historical question of how to assign credit for inventing the laser remains controversial. Most of the ideas were patented by someone, but that tells little about how the ideas actually arose and spread among scientists.

Listen: Robert Dicke recalls patenting his idea

Listen: Ali Javan comments on credit for discoveries

More reading: A historian’s thoughts on what the controversy shows about the meaning of invention

Charles Townes, a curious mind and a great teacher

02/02/2015

By David Belforte
Chief Editor, Industrial Laser Solutions

Like many, I was greatly saddened by the passing on January 27, 2015, of Charles H. Townes, the Nobel laureate whose work in Maser technology laid the foundation for the invention of the laser.

You will be reading much about Dr. Townes—or Charles, as asked to be called—so I won’t elaborate on his technology achievements. Instead, I would like to talk about the man and his personality that caused admiring students to surround him and respond to his knowledge challenges.

I actually did not interact with Charles that much. At several international photonics conferences, we were like ships that pass in the night, on the same sea, but headed in different directions. He to more theoretically related activities and to bask under the accolades due to him as one of the fathers of the laser, and me toward the more mundane world of teaching how to profit from the use of this technology.

Many years ago, as invited speakers at a photonics conference in Vienna, Charles and I were seated together at a banquet. Between courses, I shared a personal anecdote with him about my aborted career in magnetron manufacturing—a technology dear to him, as he was awarded the Nobel for his work in microwave amplification of stimulated emission of radiation (Masers) and I had worked on the product of his theory while in the Army and later turned down employment to continue in this technology, eventually pursing photonics. This was the Charles I knew, sincerely curious about what I had to say and asking penetrating questions about my interests, not sharing his.

Several years later, we had occasion to meet again after an LIA ICALEO conference in San Diego. He joined my wife and me at a hotel guest club where he again focused in on my interests, first about New England (where I live) and then about industrial laser processing. What was intended as a brief, relaxing interlude extended into a lengthy and stimulating, for me, discussion on the place for photonics in the manufacturing world. This episode reinforced my view of Charles as a person of great curiosity, a probing and somewhat gently demanding teacher—I then understood why his students rallied to him, a friendly, inquisitive personality who drew out the best in those he met.

My last view of Charles was the next morning at the airline terminal where he charged past, tugging his carry-on, headed for his next intellectual event at the age of 94—an inspiring figure I will l always recall with admiration.